Georgia’s Broken Parole System

Georgia’s parole system is deeply flawed, causing confusion, delays, and emotional strain for inmates and their families. Despite its purpose to help inmates reintegrate into society, the system lacks transparency, applies inconsistent standards, and operates inefficiently. Here’s a quick breakdown:

Key Problems:
- Unclear Decision-Making: Decisions are made without explanation or group discussions.
- Lack of Transparency: Families and the public cannot access decision details.
- Inconsistent Standards: Parole criteria vary widely, creating confusion.
- Overcrowding: Delayed parole decisions contribute to dangerous prison overcrowding.
Impact:
- Inmates and families face financial, emotional, and mental challenges.
- Taxpayers bear the cost of overcrowded, strained prison resources.
Proposed Reforms:
- Require collective reviews and public documentation of decisions.
- Establish independent oversight and clear guidelines.
- Improve communication with victims, prosecutors, and families.

Reforming Georgia’s parole system is critical for fairness, accountability, and public safety. Advocacy groups and proposed legislative changes aim to address these issues and create a more transparent and effective system.

Early parole problems: Victims and lawmakers say system is broken

Parole Decision-Making Process in Georgia

The parole process in Georgia can be confusing for inmates and their families. Decisions are made by a five-member board appointed by the governor. However, these members don’t meet to discuss cases together, leading to a disjointed approach in how parole is considered.

Criteria for Parole Eligibility and Decisions

The Parole Decision Guidelines system is used to assess cases, taking into account several factors:

The seriousness of the original crime
Conduct while in prison
Results from risk assessments
Criminal and social history
Chances of successful reintegration into society

For inmates with non-life sentences, the Board assigns a Tentative Parole Month (TPM), but this can be changed or canceled anytime before release ^[1]^[2]. For those serving life sentences, the process differs. Once eligible under Georgia law, the Board simply decides to approve or deny parole without setting a TPM. If parole is denied, the case is reviewed at least once every eight years ^[1].

Transparency and Accountability Issues

The Board’s process is often criticized for being unclear and inconsistent. Members review cases independently and don’t explain their decisions, which raises transparency concerns.

Issue	Effect
Independent Voting	Decisions are made without group discussions
Lack of Clarity	Families and the public don’t have access to decision-making details
No Public Oversight	The Board’s effectiveness cannot be evaluated

"The public’s lack of access to the Board prevents evaluating its effectiveness." – Hollie Manheimer, Executive Director of the Georgia First Amendment Foundation ^[3]

Some improvements have been made through measures like HB 71 (2015), which requires notifying prosecutors and victims’ families before parole or pardon decisions ^[3]. However, the process remains mostly hidden. This lack of communication leaves inmates unsure about how to improve their chances and frustrates families who feel decisions are arbitrary ^[1]^[2].

These issues don’t just impact individuals – they also contribute to larger problems like overcrowded prisons and strained family ties.

sbb-itb-7858f51

Impact of a Flawed Parole System

Georgia’s parole system has deep flaws, creating challenges not only within prisons but also in the broader community.

Prison Overcrowding and Resource Strain

Delays in parole decisions force eligible inmates to remain behind bars longer than necessary. This leads to overcrowding, making prisons more dangerous and costly to maintain. Facilities like Valdosta State Prison illustrate this problem, with six inmate deaths reported in 2022 – none of which were independently disclosed by officials ^[5].

Overcrowding impacts several critical areas:

Area	Consequences
Safety	Higher rates of violence and deaths
Healthcare	Overburdened medical staff and services
Infrastructure	Faster wear and tear on facilities
Taxpayer Costs	Increased spending to house inmates longer

Effects on Families of Incarcerated Individuals

The consequences of this broken system extend beyond prison walls. Families of incarcerated individuals face mounting financial, emotional, and mental challenges due to unclear and delayed parole decisions.

Some of the most pressing issues include:

Financial Strain: Families lose income while also covering legal fees and visitation costs.
Emotional Toll: Prolonged separation and uncertainty take a heavy emotional toll.
Mental Health Struggles: Both inmates and their families suffer from the stress and trauma caused by indefinite imprisonment, often creating generational cycles of hardship.

"The people of Georgia have the right and need to know what is going on behind prison walls in our state" ^[4]

Reforming the parole system is essential to bring transparency, fairness, and accountability to Georgia’s justice system.

Efforts Toward Parole System Reform

Various organizations and stakeholders are actively working to address the challenges within Georgia’s parole system through advocacy and proposed changes.

Advocacy by Groups like Georgia Prisoners’ Speak

Georgia Prisoners’ Speak (GPS) plays a key role in highlighting problems within the prison system by:

Documenting poor and inhumane conditions.
Advocating for the protection of constitutional rights.
Acting as a bridge between incarcerated individuals and stakeholders.

Groups like the Georgia First Amendment Foundation have also drawn attention to transparency concerns, setting the stage for meaningful reform efforts within the parole system.

Proposed Reforms for a Better Parole System

Advocacy efforts have led to actionable proposals aimed at addressing the core issues of the parole system. These proposals focus on three main areas:

Reform Area	Proposed Solutions
Decision-Making & Transparency	– Require collective board reviews – Publicly document decisions – Conduct regular audits of decision patterns
Oversight & Accountability	– Form an independent oversight committee – Provide written justifications for decisions – Offer public access to decision criteria
Victim & Prosecutor Rights	– Notify victims and prosecutors in advance of parole decisions – Allow input during the decision process

Some of the key measures being pushed include:

Overhauling the Decision Process
- Implement mandatory full-board reviews for all cases.
- Introduce clear documentation standards for decisions.
- Establish independent oversight to ensure accountability.
Improving Transparency
- Update the Georgia Open Records Act to include full access to prison records ^[4].
- Make parole decision criteria publicly available.
- Require regular reporting on parole board activities.
Involving Stakeholders
- Notify prosecutors and victims’ families well in advance of decisions ^[3].
- Provide formal avenues for stakeholders to share their input.
- Regularly evaluate the system’s effectiveness to ensure continuous improvement.

These proposed changes aim to create a parole system that prioritizes fairness, accountability, and public safety while respecting the rights of all involved.

Conclusion: Need for Transparent and Fair Parole Practices

Challenges and Potential Solutions

Georgia’s parole system faces serious issues that require immediate attention. Parole board members often review cases without clear accountability or consistency, which creates significant problems, particularly for inmates serving life sentences. These decisions frequently lack clear guidelines, leaving many in the dark about their future ^[1]^[3].

The effects of these practices go far beyond the prison system. Overcrowded prisons, fueled by strict sentencing laws and inconsistent parole decisions, strain state resources and deeply impact families across Georgia ^[2].

Steps Toward Reform

Reforming Georgia’s parole system will require collaboration from various stakeholders. Priorities for improvement include:

Public oversight mechanisms to ensure transparency and accountability
Improved communication with families about parole decisions
Legislative action to hold parole boards accountable
Adopting evidence-based practices for more consistent and fair parole outcomes

Citizens play a crucial role in driving reform. Here’s how you can help:

Support advocacy groups like Georgia Prisoners’ Speak, which shed light on systemic problems
Contact state representatives to demand transparency and fairness in parole decisions
Get involved with reform initiatives that push for better practices in the justice system

These changes align with the efforts of organizations fighting to uphold constitutional rights and improve conditions within Georgia’s criminal justice system. Tackling the flaws in the parole system is a vital step toward creating a justice system that works for everyone.

John Quick

See Full Bio