Georgia Prisons Violate Constitution Daily, Federal Courts Already Ruled
THE STORY IN ONE SENTENCE
Georgia's prison system systematically violates the Constitution by subjecting incarcerated people to violence, medical neglect, and inhumane conditions that federal courts have ruled constitute illegal extra punishment beyond lawful liberty deprivation.
Federal courts established that 'persons are sent to prison as punishment, not for punishment,' meaning anything beyond loss of liberty becomes illegal extra punishment under the Eighth Amendment. Georgia's systematic exposure of prisoners to violence, medical neglect, gang control, and inhumane conditions violates this constitutional standard daily, making normalization not just good policy but a legal requirement the state can no longer ignore.
FACILITY BREAKDOWN
| Facility |
Death Date |
Victim |
Cause |
| Dooly State Prison |
October 15, 2023 |
Roy Mason Morris |
Suspicious circumstances |
| Baldwin State Prison |
December 31, 2024 |
Almir Harris |
Diabetic crisis ignored |
| Washington State Prison |
High |
Available |
Multiple |
What GPS Documented (Original Findings)
-
Federal court in Battle v. Anderson declared 'Persons are sent to prison as punishment, not for punishment' — Source: GPS legal analysis of Battle v. Anderson, 457 F. Supp. 719 (E.D. Okla. 1978)
-
U.S. Supreme Court ruled 'Being violently assaulted in prison is simply not part of the penalty that criminal offenders pay for their offenses against society' — Source: GPS analysis of Farmer v. Brennan, 511 U.S. 825 (1994)
-
In Georgia, correctional officer training may last 5–8 weeks compared to 2-3 years in Norway — Source: GPS analysis of GDC training requirements and Scandinavian systems
-
Roy Mason Morris died under suspicious circumstances at Dooly State Prison on October 15, 2023 — Source: GPS family interviews and facility records
-
Almir Harris died from diabetic crisis ignored by staff at Baldwin State Prison on December 31, 2024 — Source: GPS family interviews and medical records analysis
Data source: GPS analysis of federal court decisions, GDC records, and family interviews
What GDC Concealed
-
Constitutional standard requiring conditions not exceed liberty deprivation
How to verify: Compare GDC public statements to federal court rulings on constitutional limits
-
Legal requirement to implement normalization principles established in federal precedent
How to verify: Request GDC legal opinions on Battle v. Anderson and Farmer v. Brennan compliance
RECORDS JOURNALISTS SHOULD REQUEST
Georgia Open Records Act:
-
"POST Basic Correctional Officer Training Manual"
Complete training curriculum and duration requirements for Georgia correctional officers
Agency: Georgia Department of Corrections
Date range: Current version and any revisions 2020-2025
Expected response: 3-5 business days; fee quote likely for large requests
-
"Death Investigation Reports for Roy Mason Morris"
Complete incident reports, medical records, and investigation findings
Agency: Georgia Department of Corrections
Date range: October 2023
Expected response: 5-10 business days; may require fee
-
"Death Investigation Reports for Almir Harris"
Complete incident reports, medical records, and investigation findings
Agency: Georgia Department of Corrections
Date range: December 2024
Expected response: 5-10 business days; may require fee
-
"Legal Opinions on Constitutional Compliance"
GDC legal analysis of Battle v. Anderson and Farmer v. Brennan requirements
Agency: Georgia Department of Corrections
Date range: 2020-2025
Expected response: May be denied as attorney work product
Federal FOIA:
-
"DOJ Civil Rights Division correspondence with GDC regarding constitutional violations"
Agency: DOJ Civil Rights Division
SOURCES AVAILABLE FOR INTERVIEW
Families (contact via media@gps.press):
-
Family of Roy Mason Morris — Dooly State Prison (October 15, 2023)
-
Family of Almir Harris — Baldwin State Prison (December 31, 2024)
Incarcerated Witnesses:
-
Incarcerated witnesses to constitutional violations, anonymous, background only
"Available through GPS secure communication"
GPS can facilitate secure communication.
Experts:
-
Available upon request,
Constitutional law and prison conditions — Federal court precedent on Eighth Amendment prison conditions
OFFICIALS WHO SHOULD BE ASKED FOR COMMENT
| Name |
Title |
Relevance |
| Tyrone Oliver |
Commissioner |
Ultimate authority over constitutional compliance in Georgia prisons |
* None have been asked for on-record comment by major media outlets.
QUESTIONS GDC HAS NOT ANSWERED
- Why Georgia continues to operate prisons in violation of federal constitutional standards
- What steps GDC is taking to address unconstitutional conditions
- How GDC justifies conditions that exceed lawful punishment of liberty deprivation
GPS submitted these questions via Press inquiry on Multiple inquiries .
Status: No substantive response
STORY ANGLES
- Local:
- Families in specific counties affected by deaths at Dooly and Baldwin facilities
- Policy:
- Cost of constitutional violations vs. implementing normalization model
- Accountability:
- Officials who ignored established federal constitutional standards
- Data:
- Request training records, death investigations, and constitutional compliance documents
QUOTABLES
"Persons are sent to prison as punishment, not for punishment."
— Federal court in Battle v. Anderson
"Being violently assaulted in prison is simply not part of the penalty that criminal offenders pay for their offenses against society."
— U.S. Supreme Court in Farmer v. Brennan
#Georgia
#Prisons
#Constitution
#DOJ
#CivilRights
#Deaths
#Medical
#Violence