Prison Economics/Poverty
Economic Exploitation in Prison: Wages, Fees, and the Poverty Cycle
This first-person essay by incarcerated writer Demetrius Buckley, published by the Vera Institute of Justice, documents the economic exploitation of incarcerated people and their families in Michigan prisons. Key findings include average prison wages of $12-$16/month, mandatory labor enforced by threat of solitary confinement, and data showing 65% of families with incarcerated loved ones cannot meet basic needs due to court-related debt averaging over $13,000. The piece contextualizes mass incarceration as a driver of poverty in Black and brown communities and introduces Vera's new Incarceration and Inequality Project (IIP) Data Explorer tool.
Key Findings
The most impactful data from this research collection.
$12.00
$12-$16/month: Michigan prison wages
Statistic65%
65% of families unable to meet basic needs
Statistic$13,000
$13,000+ average court debt per family
StatisticVendors target families, not incarcerated people
FindingAll Data Points
21 verified data points extracted from primary sources.
Average Michigan prison wages: $12-$16 per month Statistic
Incarcerated people in Michigan prisons earn an average of $12 to $16 per month from prison jobs, depending on their court circumstance and job description.
$12.00 vs. dollars per month (high end)
65% of families with incarcerated loved ones unable to meet basic needs Statistic
According to a survey by the Ella Baker Center, roughly 65 percent of families with a loved one in prison were unable to meet their basic needs because court-related fines and fees sent them into debt of more than $13,000 on average.
65%
Average court-related debt exceeds $13,000 per family Statistic
Court-related fines and fees send families with an incarcerated loved one into debt of more than $13,000 on average, according to the Ella Baker Center.
$13,000
58% of families cannot afford costs associated with conviction Statistic
According to the Prison Policy Initiative, 58 percent of families could not afford 'the costs associated with a conviction.'
58%
Commissary shoes cost $70+ Statistic
The institution offered access to vendors that supply shoes costing more than $70 to incarcerated people via kiosk ordering.
$70.00
Securepak food orders cost up to $150 Statistic
Securepak orders (food items) available to incarcerated people cost up to $150.
$150.00
Tablet costs with entertainment exceed $500 Statistic
A tablet available to incarcerated people, including the purchase of music and games, can be worth more than $500.
$500.00
Footlocker storage costs $150 Statistic
Author paid $150 for an aluminum footlocker from Michigan State Industries to store belongings beyond the one green duffle bag limit per person. Items that cannot fit inside the duffle bag are labeled contraband and destroyed.
$150.00
Mandatory labor in Michigan prisons enforced by threat of solitary Policy
Labor in Michigan prisons is mandatory. Not participating in the job pool could lead the incarcerated person to long-time isolation.
Tariff-driven price increases burden incarcerated people and families since 2025 Trend
Since 2020, incarcerated people have been receiving email blasts explaining price spikes in clothing and food items available from the kiosk. In 2025, the price rose again due to tariff wars, further burdening incarcerated people and their families.
Incarcerated people's property limited to one duffle bag Policy
Incarcerated people in Michigan prisons are limited to one green duffle bag per person. Any item that can't fit inside is labeled contraband and destroyed.
Poorest communities most policed and funneled into prison Finding
The poorest communities are the ones most policed and funneled into prison. A high percentage of incarcerated bodies are poor Black and brown people.
Vendors target families rather than incarcerated people for payment Finding
Vendors offering shoes, food packages, tablets, and other items aim not for the incarcerated person to pay, but their family and friends, given that prison wages of $12-$16/month are wholly insufficient to cover these costs.
Paying debt to society does not repair victims' families Finding
Paying a debt to society has less to do with repairing the victim's family's true desires, especially when both victim and perpetrator are from the same demographics. The author's time and money went to MDOC rather than to victims or communities.
Constitutional provision allows prisoners to be in servitude Legal fact
The United States Constitution declares prisoners to be in servitude, which the author characterizes as being 'a slave to the economic serving of the state.'
Court-ordered fees and restitutions garnished from trust accounts Case detail
Upon sentencing in 2010, court-ordered fees and restitutions were set to be garnished from a trust account set up by the state for the incarcerated person, establishing the economic framework for incarceration from the outset.
Vera Institute launches Incarceration and Inequality Project Data Explorer Finding
Vera's new Incarceration and Inequality Project (IIP) Data Explorer is an interactive tool that gives advocates and policymakers ready access to data on the connection between incarceration and economic indicators—both nationally and within their co…
Quote: Economic exploitation of incarcerated people by MDOC Quote
"My time and money went to MDOC, which makes top dollar off me and other incarcerated people."
Quote: It cost money to be poor Quote
"It cost money to be poor, and it seemed to be a major reason for crime to run rampant in low-income neighborhoods."
Quote: Paying a debt to society has less to do with repairing the victim's family Quote
"Paying a debt to society has less to do with helping or repairing the victim's family's true desires, especially if both victim and perpetrator are from the same demographic."
Quote: Vendors target families not incarcerated people Quote
"Those vendors aim not for the incarcerated person to pay, but their family and friends."
Sources
3 cited sources backing this research.
Primary
Official report
Ella Baker Center survey on families and incarceration costs
Primary
Journalism
Primary
Official report
Prison Policy Initiative: Costs associated with conviction
Key Entities
Organizations, people, facilities, and other named entities referenced in this research.
Demetrius Buckley
[person]
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
[organization]
Incarceration and Inequality Project
[program]
Michigan Department of Corrections
[organization]
Michigan State Industries
[organization]
Prison Policy Initiative
[organization]
Securepak
[organization]
Vera Institute of Justice
[organization]
Related Topics
Research topics that draw on data from this collection.
Communications & Technology
Georgia has built a $50 million contraband technology apparatus to block illicit cellphones—yet record deaths, soaring violence, and a flood of recovered phones reveal a system that enriches private vendors and the state rather than ensuring safety. While the Department of Corrections collects $8 million per year in phone-call kickbacks, families are forced to pay outrageous commissary markups and communication fees that push them into debt, making them the hidden financiers of a broken prison system.
2,149 data points
Policy & Advocacy
Georgia's prison system consumes $1.8 billion in taxpayer funds annually while failing to deliver safety, rehabilitation, or basic human dignity. This article maps the policy architecture that perpetuates these failures, the advocacy strategies challenging them, and the evidence-based reforms that could redirect Georgia's punitive machinery toward genuine public safety.
4,094 data points
Prison Labor & Economics
Georgia's prison system functions as an extraction economy, compelling incarcerated people to produce billions in goods and services for virtually no pay while their families are forced to subsidize the system through predatory commissary markups and monopoly communications prices. This cycle of exploitation is rooted in the 13th Amendment's exception clause and reinforced by perverse institutional incentives that profit from human suffering.
2,468 data points
Racial Disparities
Racial inequities permeate every stage of Georgia’s criminal legal system, yet state data rarely reveal the full scale. Available figures show Black Georgians are at least twice as likely as white Georgians to be under probation supervision, while the state’s massive probation and prison systems—combined with commissary extraction and court debt—impose severe economic harms that fall hardest on communities of color.
1,834 data points
Recidivism & Reentry
Georgia’s public narrative touts a low three-year felony reconviction rate of 25–27%, but this narrow metric masks a deeper crisis: the state releases 14,000–16,000 people annually with minimal reentry support, contributing to a national five-year rearrest rate of 76.6%. With nearly one in three incarcerated people over 50, spiraling healthcare costs, and a parole system that achieves a 72% successful completion rate, Georgia faces a stark choice between investing in evidence-based reentry or absorbing the escalating fiscal and human costs of system failure.
1,574 data points
Solitary Confinement
Georgia's use of solitary confinement and restrictive housing exposes prisoners to documented psychological devastation, racial disparity, and systemic neglect — conditions so severe that federal courts have imposed daily fines on the Georgia Department of Corrections for flagrant violations of its own settlement agreements. Georgia's Special Management Unit held 78% of its population in isolation for more than two years as of 2017, while staffing vacancies exceeding 70% at the state's largest facilities made meaningful oversight, programming, or humane treatment functionally impossible. The data, drawn from court records, federal investigations, and peer-reviewed research, reveals a system where isolation is used not as a last resort but as a default response — with predictable and measurable consequences for mental health, safety, and human dignity.
791 data points